Methodology
Bathroom remodeling in Central Indiana is competitive. To find the top companies for December 2025, we combined independent review platforms (Angi/HomeAdvisor and BBB) and prioritized contractors with:
- High star ratings (typically 4.5+ when volume is meaningful)
- Significant verified review volume (to reduce “small-sample” bias)
- BBB ratings / accreditation (trust marker and complaint-handling signal)
- Experience & specialization (bathroom-only vs. general remodeling)
- Service differentiation (one-day installs, custom tile, accessibility, design-build process)
Scope: Indianapolis metro and adjacent Central Indiana counties. National brands are included only when they have a strong local presence and strong local signals.
Top bathroom remodeling companies (ranked)
Here are the top performers based on verified review strength, BBB trust markers, and clear differentiation in services and delivery.
| Rank | Company | Best for | Why it ranks here |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Updike Bathroom Remodeling (Indianapolis)
Bathroom-only specialist
|
Bath-specific remodels with long history and high verified satisfaction | Near-perfect verified reviews plus A+ BBB trust markers and deep specialization in bathrooms. |
| 2 |
Worthington Design & Remodeling / Case Design Remodel (Carmel & Indianapolis)
Design-build / premium
|
High-end bathrooms with design support and full project management | Strong review base and trust markers paired with a large design-build team for complex projects. |
| 3 |
Central Construction Group (Central Indiana)
Full-service remodeling
|
Custom remodels with licensed, managed delivery | Very strong verified sentiment plus professional credentials; solid pick for bigger bath scopes. |
| 4 |
Bath Fitter (Indianapolis)
Fast conversion
|
Quick tub/shower updates with minimal downtime | High verified ratings + BBB trust markers; ideal for homeowners prioritizing speed and simplicity. |
| 5 |
Bath Experts (Indianapolis & Midwest)
One-day systems
|
One-day transformations using premium product lines | Strong trust markers and good review sentiment, though smaller review volume than the leaders. |
| 6 |
Superior Bath System (Fishers/Indianapolis)
Local specialist
|
Balanced value and quality with strong local satisfaction signals | Excellent rating distribution with BBB trust markers; a solid contender for mid-range remodels. |
| 7 |
Indy Renovation (Indianapolis)
Remodel + plumbing
|
Projects needing plumbing and broader remodeling support | Long history and BBB trust markers, but mixed review distribution lowers its placement. |
| 8 |
Booher Remodeling Company (Indianapolis)
Design center
|
Homeowners who want guided selections and a structured process | BBB trust markers and positive sentiment; smaller verified review sample keeps it lower. |
| 9 |
New Bath Today (Indianapolis)
Product-backed remodels
|
KOHLER-aligned systems and visualization-first planning | Solid trust markers and mid-to-high rating signals; lower total review footprint than the top group. |
Tip: If you want a full tile bath (custom waterproofing, niches, benches), focus on design-build and full-service remodelers. For speed, one-day systems are a better fit.
Company profiles (fast detail)
1) Updike Bathroom Remodeling — bathroom-only specialist with long history
Updike ranks first for a simple reason: it combines bathroom-only specialization with high verified satisfaction and strong trust markers. This is a top choice for homeowners who want a dedicated bathroom contractor that consistently delivers on communication, cleanliness, and schedule.
2) Worthington / Case — best for premium design-build bathrooms
A strong fit for larger or more design-forward bathrooms. Worthington/Case’s strength is its design-build structure: planning, renderings, selections, permitting, and project management are coordinated in one system—ideal when multiple trades must be tightly sequenced.
3) Central Construction Group — licensed full-service remodeler for complex scopes
Central Construction Group stands out for homeowners who want a full remodel handled end-to-end. Expect a more comprehensive approach: design, permitting, and managed execution across trades. Great for layout changes, custom tile, and higher-budget projects.
4) Bath Fitter — best for speed and minimal disruption
Bath Fitter is ideal when you want a clean, quick transformation without living in a construction zone. Their model fits tub-to-shower conversions and fast refreshes, often with strong warranty support.
5) Bath Experts — Jacuzzi-aligned one-day transformations
A solid choice for homeowners who want premium branded systems and a rapid install model. Review signals are strong, though the sample is smaller than top-ranked companies.
6) Superior Bath System — strong local contender with high satisfaction distribution
Often a sweet spot for homeowners balancing budget and quality. Strong review distribution suggests dependable workmanship and a stable process.
7) Indy Renovation — long-established option with mixed review distribution
A long-running contractor with BBB trust markers and broad capability, including plumbing. If you choose Indy Renovation, prioritize clear scope documents, milestones, and communication expectations up front.
8) Booher Remodeling Company — structured process and design support
A good fit if you want a guided selection experience and a company that can coordinate bathroom work as part of a larger home update. Smaller review sample keeps it from ranking higher.
9) New Bath Today — KOHLER-aligned systems + visualization
New Bath Today is a product-forward option with an emphasis on visualization and systemized installs. Works well for homeowners who prefer structured packages and brand-backed products.
How to choose a bathroom remodeler (fast checklist)
- Waterproofing plan: ask what system is used behind tile (and how corners/curbs are handled).
- Scope clarity: confirm who handles plumbing, electrical, ventilation, and permits.
- Timeline: get a start date + “days on site” estimate, plus what causes delays.
- Change orders: confirm pricing rules for upgrades (tile, fixtures, layout changes).
- Warranty: request workmanship warranty terms in writing.
- Cleanup & protection: dust control, flooring protection, daily cleanup expectations.
Renovation planning: compare with Top Kitchen Remodelers and Top Countertop Installers to coordinate trades and finish schedules.