How the Ranking Was Determined
I searched for gutter-replacement and repair companies that serve the Indianapolis/Central Indiana region and collected data from reliable review aggregators (Angi, TrustAnalytica, TrustIndex, 5-Star Business, and others), company websites, and BBB profiles when available. The ranking emphasizes customer satisfaction (average rating and review volume) and weighs additional signals such as BBB standing, years in business, certifications, warranties, responsiveness, and local community involvement.
Raptor Roofing is placed at #4 because, although newer than some competitors, it maintains a perfect public rating, has completed a high volume of jobs, and regularly supports community initiatives in Greenwood and the wider Indianapolis area.
Top Gutter Repair & Replacement Companies
1. Indy Roof & Restoration (Indianapolis)
Indy Roof & Restoration shows a near-perfect average rating paired with one of the largest publicly visible review counts in the market. The company is known for quick response times and insurance-claim guidance, and it offers roofing, siding, and gutter services with complimentary inspections.
Why ranked first: Exceptional review volume combined with a near-perfect rating suggests consistently strong performance at scale.
2. Big Boy’s Construction (Indianapolis)
Big Boy’s Construction earns strong public ratings with hundreds of reviews and is frequently praised for clear explanations and integrity. The company provides gutters, roofing, siding, and storm restoration services with experience that spans decades.
Why ranked second: Strong rating, strong volume, and long-term local presence—slightly fewer reviews than the top-ranked firm.
3. Bone Dry Roofing (Indianapolis)
Bone Dry Roofing has an enormous number of public reviews and a long history in the region. Customer feedback commonly mentions fast project completion, documentation, and clear communication during roof and gutter replacements.
Why ranked third: Slightly lower average rating than the top two, but the volume and longevity indicate reliability over time.
4. Raptor Roofing (Indianapolis / Greenwood)
Raptor Roofing (formerly Raptor Restoration) maintains a perfect public rating with a large review base and provides gutter replacement and repair alongside roofing, siding, insulation, windows, and commercial services. The company is also known for supporting community initiatives in Greenwood and the broader Indianapolis area.
Why ranked fourth: Newer than some competitors, but exceptional customer satisfaction signals and strong momentum justify a top placement.
5. David Hazen Group (Zionsville / Indianapolis)
The David Hazen Group has been operating for many years and shows strong public satisfaction signals with a large volume of reviews. The company offers broad home-repair services and is frequently recognized for dependable gutter-related work.
Why ranked fifth: A strong blend of rating, review volume, and long-term reliability.
6. Northside Window & Gutter Cleaning (Fishers)
Northside focuses heavily on exterior cleaning and gutter services and earns consistently strong homeowner feedback for thorough work and cleanup. Its specialization helps it stand out against larger multi-trade contractors.
Why ranked sixth: Nearly perfect ratings and niche focus, with a smaller review base than the top-ranked companies.
7. Moss Roofing (Indianapolis)
Moss Roofing is a long-running family business with strong customer feedback on workmanship and communication. It provides roofing and gutter replacement services and maintains a solid public reputation.
Why ranked seventh: Excellent rating and longevity, but fewer total reviews than higher-ranked competitors.
8. Kingdom Roofing Systems (Marion County)
Kingdom Roofing Systems shows substantial review volume with a solid average rating. Feedback highlights workmanship and warranty handling, with occasional mixed comments that place it below the top tier.
Why ranked eighth: Good reputation at scale, but slightly more variance in feedback than the companies above.
9. Cochran Exteriors (Indianapolis)
Cochran Exteriors performs a high volume of exterior projects, including gutters. Customer survey data reflects solid satisfaction and project delivery, though the average rating is lower than the companies ranked above.
Why ranked ninth: Reputable and established, with slightly lower average satisfaction signals.
10. Better Gutter Co (Indianapolis)
Better Gutter Co emphasizes direct communication and a streamlined gutter-only operation. A perfect public rating suggests strong customer satisfaction, but fewer reviews and a shorter track record place it lower than larger, longer-established competitors.
Why ranked tenth: Excellent satisfaction signals, but limited review volume relative to the market leaders.
11. The Brothers That Just Do Gutters (Indianapolis)
This gutter-specialized franchise maintains excellent public ratings and focuses exclusively on gutters and guards. The smaller number of publicly visible reviews limits placement despite strong feedback.
Why ranked eleventh: Great niche option, but not enough public review volume to rank higher on an evidence-weighted list.
Note: Some platforms require logins to view full review datasets (e.g., Yelp or Facebook). Rankings reflect publicly accessible information.
